Looking for creative non-candy Easter egg fillers that kids, tweens, and teens will actually enjoy?
If you’re avoiding sugar overload or just want unique surprises, there are plenty of small Easter egg gifts that kids of all ages will enjoy.
From mini toys and fidget gadgets to beauty items and tech accessories, here are 120 fun ideas to fill those Easter eggs without a single piece of candy.
Best Easter Egg Stuffers
I’ve broken this list down by age group to make it easier for you to find the best Easter egg stuffers that are age appropriate.
Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Toddlers & Preschoolers (Ages 1-4)
Perfect for little hands, these fillers focus on sensory fun, learning, and safe play.
- Finger puppets – Fun for storytelling
- Mini rubber duckies – Great for bath time
- Chunky crayons – Easy for tiny hands to grip
- Play-Doh Eggs – A creative favorite
- Soft Foam Stickers – No mess and safe
- Suction cup toys – Stick to windows or tables
- Mini board books – Durable for little readers
- Peek-a-boo scarves – Great for sensory play
- Mini Bubble wands – Perfect outdoor fun
- Wind-up toys – Simple and engaging
- Large beads (for threading) – Great fine motor skill activity
- Color-changing bath tablets – Makes bath time exciting
- Mini plush animals – Soft and cuddly
- Baby-safe mirrors – Fun for self-discovery
- Stacking cups (small ones) – Encourages hand-eye coordination
- Musical egg shakers – Perfect for little hands
- Soft fabric wrist rattles – Gentle and engaging
- Squishy bath toys – Fun and easy to clean
- Large foam letters or numbers – Great for early learning
- Water coloring cards – Reusable and mess-free
Find the Best Cash Back Deals Online with Rakuten!
I’ve used Rakuten to earn over $2,100 so far! Read my full Rakuten Review.
Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Elementary-Aged Kids (Ages 5-9)
Kids in this age group love small toys, crafts, and games that encourage play and creativity.
- Mini LEGO sets – Perfect for builders
- Glow-in-the-dark stars – Fun for bedroom decor
- Mini fidget poppers – Keeps little hands busy
- Mini slinky – A classic toy they’ll love
- Stickers (themed sets) – Great for notebooks and crafts
- Temporary tattoos – Fun and easy to apply
- Mini notebooks – Perfect for doodles and notes
- Mini gel pens – Bright and colorful
- Silly putty – Stretch and bounce fun
- Mini animal figurines – Perfect for playtime
- Small stampers – Great for arts and crafts
- Mini puzzle cubes – A fun challenge
- Mini yo-yo – Classic and entertaining
- Parachute toy men – Toss and watch them glide
- Mini frisbees – Perfect for backyard play
- Tiny race cars (Hot Wheels size) – A favorite for many
- Glow bracelets – Fun for nighttime play
- Kaleidoscope viewer – A mesmerizing toy
- Mini maze games – Fun for brain development
- Water bead packs – Just add water for sensory fun
Suggested Read: Homemade Easter Basket Ideas to Make
Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Tweens (Ages 10-12)
Tweens enjoy trendy accessories, creative items, and fidget-friendly toys.
- Mini Pop It keychains – Trendy and fun
- Bracelets (friendship or charm style) – Wearable and cute
- Mini nail polish – Fun for DIY manicures
- Lip balm – Keeps lips soft and hydrated
- Tiny erasers in fun shapes – Useful and collectible
- Twisty fidget toys – Great for focus
- Small hair clips or scrunchies – Stylish and useful
- Mini DIY sticker books – Perfect for customizing notebooks
- Washi tape rolls – Great for decorating journals
- Mini Rubik’s cubes – A fun brain challenge
- Pocket-sized joke books – Keep them laughing
- Mini flashlights – Handy and fun
- Tiny perfume rollers – Travel-friendly scents
- DIY charm kits – Make your own jewelry
- Tiny slime or putty – Satisfying sensory play
- Mini digital pets (Tamagotchi style) – Retro and fun
- Scratch-off reward tickets – Make your own prize system
- Mini word search or crossword booklets – Brain-stimulating fun
- Small travel-sized board games – Great for on-the-go
- Mini slingshot toys – Soft foam versions work best
Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Teens (Ages 13-18)
Teens appreciate tech accessories, beauty products, and practical everyday items.
- Earbud organizers – No more tangled wires
- Mini phone stands – Great for video watching
- PopSockets (if they fit!) – Secure grip for phones
- Screen cleaner wipes – Keep devices smudge-free
- Mini stylus pens – Useful for tablets
- Cable protectors – Helps extend charger life
- Tiny USB flash drives – Handy for school
- Blue light glasses (foldable) – Protects eyes from screens
- Mini pocket mirrors – Perfect for on-the-go
- Mini candles – Relaxing scents for their room
- Hand sanitizer (fun scents) – Travel-friendly
- Magnetic bookmarks – Great for book lovers
- Mini Sudoku or trivia cards – Fun brain games
- Cute keychains – Aesthetic and trendy
- Mini lip gloss tubes – Subtle and hydrating
- Tiny sticky notes – Perfect for reminders
- Roll-on essential oils – Relaxing scents
- Temporary hair chalk – Fun and washable
- Mini sketchpads – Great for artists
- Concert or event ticket (folded inside the egg) – A fun surprise
Bonus: DIY & Experience-Based Easter Egg Fillers
These non-toy, non-candy ideas work for any age!
- Movie tickets – See how to get cheap and free movie tickets!
- DIY coupon for a special treat – Ice cream, a fun activity, etc.
- Personalized notes of encouragement – Make their day
- Miniature DIY craft kits – Fun weekend activity
- Gift cards (small amounts) – See how to get free Starbucks gift cards
- Mini fortune teller paper games – Nostalgic fun
- Mini seed packets – Grow flowers or herbs
- Handwritten jokes on scrolls – A cute touch
- Music playlist suggestion written on a note – Share your favorites
- Funny or inspirational quotes folded inside – Daily motivation for Teens
Suggested Read: How to Get a Free Walmart Gift Card
Healthy Snacks & Fun Treats
These healthy snacks and fun treats can serve as candy alternatives!
- Trail mix packets – A healthy alternative
- Dried fruit snacks – Naturally sweet
- Mini cheese crackers – A great salty option
- Granola bars (mini ones) – Nutritious and filling
- Apple chips – Crunchy and delicious
- Mini popcorn bags – A great surprise snack
- Veggie straws (small bags) – Kids love them
- Fruit snack rolls – Tasty and natural
- Peanut butter or almond butter packs – If no allergies
- Yogurt-covered raisins – A sweet, healthy treat
What to Put in Easter Eggs Final Thoughts
Finding fun non-candy Easter egg fillers by age makes the hunt way more exciting without all the sugar overload.
Toddlers love little sensory toys, kids get a kick out of crafts and mini games, tweens are all about trendy stuff, and teens appreciate things they’ll actually use.
So mix it up, have fun with it, and make this year’s Easter egg hunt one they’ll remember!
Next, you may be interested in reading about Simple Lemonade Stand Ideas for kids that are cheap and easy to do!
